MINUTES
Petroleum Storage Tank Insurance Fund
Board of Trustees
Meeting

March 31, 2004

 
 

Chairman Abernathy called the meeting to order.

 
Trustees Present: Absent:
Robert L. Abernathy, Chairman
Judy Baker, Vice Chairman
James Ford
Ron Hooker
Tom Kolb
Don McNutt
Joyce Murphy
Dan Schuette (Designee for Steve Mahfood)
William "Bart" Creech III
Gary O'Neal
Staff Present:
Carol R. Eighmey, Executive Director
Tim Duggan, Assistant Attorney General
Terry M. Nichols, Administrative Assistant
Pat Vuchetich, General Claims Manager
H. Patrick Eriksen, Williams & Company Consulting
Ray Lentz, Operations Manager
David Pate, Claims Manager

Claim 61162 Appeal - Rhodes 101, Cape Girardeau
Trustees reviewed the summary in their notebooks; Carol Eighmey explained that the appeal was not filed timely, but said that recent conversation with the policyholder and review of the facts led her to recommend that an additional $4,000 payment be made. Chairman Abernathy directed the Board to discuss the appeal and make its decision in closed session.

Approval of Minutes
Don McNutt moved that the minutes from the January 28, 2004 meeting be approved. Judy Baker seconded the motion, which carried.

Monthly Reports
Financial reports and activity reports were reviewed. Ms. Eighmey directed the Trustees' attention to recent correspondence concerning the audit and the format of information prepared for use by the Office of Administration in the Missouri Consolidated Annual Financial Report, including the presentation of fixed assets. Ms. Murphy said she was not familiar with the details, but it appears the issue is being worked out. Ms. Eighmey noted she had not had any conversation with DNR about the issue.

Dan Schuette moved that the Board release funding for the Hold claims; Jim Ford seconded. Motion carried.

Ms. Eighmey noted trends of PSTIF insureds indicate the typical policyholder owns fewer sites than five years ago, indicating there are more Fund participants who own only one site. She observed that in its early years, the Fund could reach the majority of its policyholders via communications with the Petroleum Marketers Association and the Missouri Oil Council, but that is no longer true. Discussion followed, during which it was noted that more proactive efforts at training and communicating with tank owners may be in order. Trustees encouraged staff of the PSTIF, DNR and Department of Agriculture to be aware of the trend.

DNR Report - First Half FY04
Trustees reviewed the mid-year report; there were no questions.

Cash Flow Projections
Pat Eriksen presented the semi-annual cash flow projections; a copy of his presentation is attached. Among the points he emphasized was that the underlying assumptions include changes resulting from the recently-issued RBCA Guidance, such as the following: increased site characterization costs, reduced excavation costs, and reduced groundwater monitoring costs. He emphasized that the projected impacts of RBCA are preliminary and that after 18-24 months' implementation and experience, better projections will be possible. It was clarified that transport load fee revenues will cease at the sunset date of the program, December 31, 2010, and that at that time the Fund will need to have sufficient cash reserves to pay for completion of all ongoing cleanups. Carol Eighmey reminded the Board that an actuarial study will be commissioned later in the calendar year.

Report on RBCA
The summary memorandum in the Trustees' notebooks was reviewed. Chairman Abernathy asked when remediation activities will pick up; Ms. Eighmey said many cleanups that have been stalled should be completed relatively quickly under the new Guidance, and said she had challenged Fund staff to get 150 claims closed by Christmas, and another 150 by Memorial Day 2005. She noted that accomplishing this will require additional efforts to educate and inform the environmental consultants who do work for tank owners.

John Balkenbush added further explanation, acknowledging that there had been some shortcomings in the Stakeholder process but emphasizing the Department's commitment to get the Guidance issued and work with stakeholders to implement it successfully. He said the Department is still open to making further improvements in the Guidance, and that a committee had been formed to further evaluate the approach to the indoor inhalation exposure pathway.

Legislative Report
Chairman Abernathy called attention to the list of bills under consideration by the General Assembly. Carol Eighmey indicated that some version of the bill amending the Sunshine Law will likely pass this year.

Trustees asked several questions, focusing on whether the PSTIF is still susceptible to a "sweep" to help alleviate the budget problems. Ms. Eighmey encouraged continued efforts to educate legislators on why the PSTIF must have cash reserves for its long-term liabilities.

Jim Ford also asked whether SB718 will affect the PSTIF; Ms. Eighmey responded that it does not appear to impact the Fund's operations.

Report on Inspections
It was reported that the inspections being done by the Board's contractor, Rounds & Associates, are underway.

Judy Baker reported that the Budget Committee had met to finalize a recommendation for the Board's consideration regarding funding for DNR and whether to utilize the Department to conduct PSTIF's inspections in FY05. She said the Committee was encouraged by progress made in discussions with the DNR regarding coordinated inspections, and believed cost savings could be achieved. She presented the Committee's recommendation that the Board approve a budget of $1,841,328 for DNR for FY05. Jim Ford seconded.

A brief discussion followed. Dan Schuette re-emphasized points he made in a recent communication to the Budget Committee, in which the Department had requested an amount equal to the FY03 budget. Chairman Abernathy noted that a year's experience will provide a better basis for future budgeting.

Carol Eighmey asked whether the Committee intended for her to complete negotiations with DNR and develop a written document that outlines what the Board and the Department are agreeing to relative to inspections. Ms. Baker affirmed that was the Committee's desires. Jim Ford agreed, and noted that a lot of issues had been resolved, including plans for better information-sharing.

The motion carried, with Dan Schuette voting against it.

Administrative Issues
Ms. Eighmey asked the Board to postpone the recommended appointment of Doug Potts to the Advisory Committee. She thanked the Board for the opportunity to attend the National UST/LUST Conference and briefly summarized some of the information gleaned from the meeting.

Trustees were reminded to file their Financial Disclosure Reports with the Ethics Commission by April 30.

Don McNutt moved that the Board go into closed session to discuss and vote on matters related to legal actions, causes of action, litigation and/or personnel issues pursuant to Section 610.021, RSMo. Jim Ford seconded, and the motion carried.

If such action is approved a majority vote of a quorum of the Board, the Board of Trustees of the Petroleum Storage Tank Insurance Fund may go into closed session at this meeting to discuss legal, confidential or privileged matters pursuant to Section 610.021, RSMo.

Back to Top